Shelter Island NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

The median home value in Shelter Island, NY is $1,240,000. This is higher than the county median home value of $344,500. The national median home value is $185,800. The average price of homes sold in Shelter Island, NY is $1,240,000. Approximately 32.13% of Shelter Island homes are owned, compared to 4.16% rented, while 63.71% are vacant. Shelter Island real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale. Commercial properties are also available. If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Shelter Island real estate agent to arrange a tour today!


Sort Results:
1–25 of 26 properties displayed
Refine Property Search
Page 1 | 2 of 2    Prev | Next
Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,895
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
0.7 Acres
Year built:
1983
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
3146139

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Chic & timeless design meet efficient modern living in this newly renovated 4 bedroom, 3 bath home. The open floor plan seamlessly integrates with the spacious & private .7 acre property creating an ideal entertaining environment. Custom cabinetry & Bertazonni appliances set the tone of uncompromising quality with finishes that are top of the line across the board. Step out of your 20 x 40 heated gunite pool, a quick pass through your outdoor shower and walk 5 minutes to boat or Salt Restaurant.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
0.12 Acres
Year built:
1887
Baths:
2.00
MLS#:
3144458

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

This 1887 Carpenter Gothic Victorian is as sweet as its porch swing and blue Hydrangeas. The front porch, chapel style doors and guest parlor welcome you to this historic home. Simple gatherings are easy to create in the open dining room and kitchen. Curl up with a book in the comfortable living room with cozy fireplace. Spend lazy afternoons at the association beach club or enjoy the summer breezes on the screened porch. The bedrooms with amazingly charming balconies are peaceful retreats.

Open House:

Saturday, 7/20 11:00-1:00PM

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,850
Status:
Active
Beds:
5
Lot size:
1.09 Acres
Year built:
1967
Baths:
2.00
MLS#:
3143259

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Better then Brand New Construction... This 5 Bedroom Cape Cod was Completely Renovated From Top to Bottom w/400 Series Anderson Windows Allowing the House to be Flooded with Daylight & The Cool Summer Breeze to Flow Through. Many Rooms Overlook the Unique Views of Trees, Bamboo & Nature from Sachem Woods and Surrounding Areas. The first Floor Features a Custom Gourmet Kitchen W/Medallion Inset Cabinets, a White Quartz Countertop & Bertazzoni SS Appliances. New Roof, Siding, Too Much to List!

Open House:

Saturday, 7/20 12:00-2:00PM

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
2,436
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
0.63 Acres
Year built:
1991
Baths:
4.00
MLS#:
3142270

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Designer Renovated Contemporary With 4 Beds, 4 Baths & Pool. Few Blocks To Wades Beach. Bright Open Plan Living Room/Dining Room/Kitchen With Glass Doors And Windows Facing Mahogany Pool Deck And Lush Back Yard. Sits Up On A Hill In A Canopy Of Oaks With Flowering Cherry, Dogwood And Japanese Maple. Enjoy Sunsets, Breezes And Winter Water View Of Protected Fresh Pond Across Street. Hardwood Floors, Separate Guest Suite, Skylights In Pantry And 2 Bathrooms, Multiple Bonus Rooms. New CAC And Roof.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
2,800
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
1.16 Acres
Year built:
1996
Baths:
4.00
MLS#:
3141848

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

The Perfect Hamptons Alternative- 110 Ft Dock And Private Beach Situated On Coecles Harbor. Enjoy The Afternoon Sea Breeze & Stunning Harbor Sunsets. Entertain In Style: Decorators Interior, Oversized Living Room, Chef's Kitchen, 3 Ensuite Bedrooms Plus Guest House W/ Lg Bedroom And Bath. Extraordinary Home For The Discerning Buyer. Seaplane Access From Nyc.

Open House:

Saturday, 7/20 10:00-12:00PM

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
Beds:
5
Lot size:
0.78 Acres
Year built:
2003
Baths:
4.00
MLS#:
3130823

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Silver Beach Waterfront shy of 1 acre. 5BR/3.5BA home. Ist Floor features Cathedral Ceilings w Skylights for a bright sun filled space. Hardwood Floors. Viking stove Kitchen. FP. Sliders open to a 20x40 Gunite Pool overlooking Floating Dock, 6' at low tide 1/2 BA next to Front Door. Master on 1st with 9' ceilings and Whirlpool Bath w Separate Shower. Second Floor has 4BR/2BA Wall-Wall carpets in BRs. WD. Pull down access to Attic Storage. Finished Bsmt, with Office TV room & Gym.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
2,706
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
0.77 Acres
Year built:
1978
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
3129653
Subdivision:
Wade Road

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

This 4BR/3BA expanded ranch is turnkey with a complete, new renovation throughout. Located across from Sylvester Manor farmlands, the sunsets are spectacular year round over the fields. The grounds host an expansive backyard with room for a pool. Raised bed gardens grace the front lawn. Interior spaces are welcoming, bright & new with appealing finishes & design. Extras: 2 ovens, wine frdge, htd garage, water softener, aprilair systems, generator, whole house air purification, safe & more

Open House:

Saturday, 7/20 10:30-12:30PM

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,656
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
1 Acres
Year built:
1979
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
3124137
Subdivision:
Westwind Knolls

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

This Spacious 4 Bedroom, 3 Bath Waterfront Modern Has Dock (@5' @ Low tide) And Waterview Heated 55' Gunite 2 Lane Swimming Pool With Beautiful Sunset Waterviews. Landscaped, Secluded And Elevated From Shore With Waterside Deck, Two Master Suites, Living Room With Fireplace, Dining Room, Heated Enclosed Porch And Kitchen All With Waterviews. There Is Also A Den, Gym, Garage, Outside Shower and Outbuilding for storage with skylight. Also opportunity for additional acre.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,785
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Lot size:
0.62 Acres
Year built:
1968
Baths:
1.00
MLS#:
3120900

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Rehabilitated mid century raised ranch on quiet street on tranquil shelter island. Many new upgrades. Room for a pool.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
3,300
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Lot size:
1.3 Acres
Year built:
1987
Baths:
4.00
MLS#:
3119152

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Secluded Waterfront Property on Menantic Creek. Boasts 2 Waterfront Master En-suites. 3rd Bedroom Also Has Water & Dock View. Floor To Ceiling Windows in Living Room and Dining Room. Surrounded by Water With Eastern & Western Light, The Living Room Centers Around The Stone Fireplace. Open Loft Area On Second Floor Overlooks LR & Creek. This Property Has Mature Plantings w/ Specimen Trees & Garden. Garden Shed. Generator, Private Legacy Dock & Lift w/ Electric & Water. Potential for a Pool.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
2.4 Acres
Year built:
1985
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
3117508

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
2,933
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
0.57 Acres
Year built:
1985
Baths:
4.00
MLS#:
3117095
Subdivision:
Silver Beach Lagoon

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

This water-view Silver Beach expanded ranch is much more than meets the eye! Its newly constructed addition allows for a large 4+BR home with bonus family room w/water view; or a spacious 3-BR home with a 1+BR Guest Suite w/wv. Bright, airy & fresh spaces, hardwood floors, CAC & BR fans, large deck for entertaining, outdoor shower & possibly room for a pool. 1-car garage & main floor laundry as well as a full basement with cedar closet, a second laundry & new & well-maintained systems throughout

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,105
Status:
Active
Beds:
2
Lot size:
0.54 Acres
Year built:
1955
Baths:
1.00
MLS#:
3115039
Subdivision:
Fresh Pond

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Enjoy stunning waterfront sunsets, surrounded by nature, from this quaint 2BR, 1BA cottage on Shelter Island's lake, known as "Fresh Pond". Entertain on your waterside elevated deck & launch your kayak after breakfast for some freshwater fishing. The living room w/wood burning fireplace overlooks the pond for cozy winter evenings. A solid home w/sleeping porch, full basement & detached garage. No concern of flooding from tide or storm surge. Your personal touch makes this the perfect get away!

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
2,228
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Lot size:
0.97 Acres
Year built:
2002
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
3105137

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Desirably located near Fresh Pond, Wade's Beach, Mashomack Preserve, and The South Ferry, a gateway to The Hamptons, this beautiful move-in ready Traditional is nestled among shade trees and offers many comforts including a stone fireplace, hardwood floors, stainless eat-In kitchen, first-floor Master- suite, 2-car attached garage, and central air. The spacious living room that allows multiple sitting areas, wrap around porch and screened porch provide many opportunities for entertaining.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
12,142
Status:
Active
Beds:
22
Lot size:
4.3 Acres
Year built:
1929
Baths:
18.00
MLS#:
3097844

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Dramatic Waterfront Estate With Sweeping Circular Driveway, 12,142 Sq Ft Cedar Shake Manor House With Entry Foyer, 4 Hearths, Commercial Kitchen, Dr/Ballroom, Lr/Bar, Windowed Porch/Sunroom, 4 Blue Stone Patios With Total 3523 Sq Ft, Sweeping Lawn To Tennis, Private Beach, Dock & 8 Moorings. Partially Finished Full Basement With Egress, Office, Spa. Ideal Private Residence Operating As The Famous Rams Head Inn, Retain Commercial Usage For Private Yacht Club, Corporate Events Or Gourmet Retreats.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
2,972
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Lot size:
2.53 Acres
Year built:
1995
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
3097495

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

This Beautiful Contemporary Has 3 Bedrooms, 2.5 Baths And An Open Floor Plan Concept So That When You Enter The Home The 2 Story Living/Dining Area Has A Stunning Water View Of Gardiners Bay And The North Fork. There Is A Water Side Deck Which Runs The Length Of The Home, Every Bedroom Has A Water View. The Home Interior Was Recently Painted And The Wood Floors Have Been Finished.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
4,174
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
2 Acres
Year built:
1888
Baths:
5.00
MLS#:
3085644
Subdivision:
Menantic Colony West

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Stunning, With Ornately Landscaped Expansive Grounds,It Creates A Classic English Countryside Atmosphere. The 1st Floor Features An Open Living Area With French Doors To The Patio Garden, Formal Dining, Eat-In-Kitchen With Butler's Pantry, Laundry & A Study. On The 2nd Floor Is The Master En-Suite With Office And Deck & 2 En-Suite Guest Rooms.It Includes A Trellis Walkway That Leads To The 2nd Floor The Carriage House, 2.5 Car Garage Below. The 18X60 Ft Pool, Flanked By Cabana & 1Br Guest House.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
3,257
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
1 Acres
Year built:
1987
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
3083393
Subdivision:
Menantic Peninsula

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Exceptional Waterfront Value! Light-Filled Modern With Dock And In-Ground Waterside Pool. Covered Porch Surrounds & Offers Elevated Views To The Water & Access From Every Room. Living & Dining Rooms & Eat In Kitchen All Look To The Water. Waterside Walkout Lower Level With Great Room, Bedroom, Bath, Laundry & Mechanicals. Mahogany Deck Surrounds In-Ground Pool. Near Salt Restaurant & The Island Boatyard.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,161
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Lot size:
0.5 Acres
Year built:
1985
Baths:
2.00
MLS#:
3076711

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Private Country Lane Setting Off South Ferry Rd. Spacious Open Ranch Floor Plan. Additional Garage Space On Lower Level With Garage Door.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,454
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Lot size:
0.75 Acres
Year built:
1958
Baths:
2.00
MLS#:
3069670
Subdivision:
Silver Beach

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Crisp & Newly Redone Mid-Century Modern Ranch On .75 Acre Plus 25' Wide Private Sandy Beach Strip On Peconic Ave. Spacious, New Mbr Suite, New Kitchen & Updates Throughout, Including Complete Insulation, Oil Tank, Electric, Plumbing, Outdoor Shower & Smart Home Features. Vaulted, Screened Dining Porch, Outdoor Tiki Bar & Two Decks For Entertaining Fun!

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
3,137
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
1.92 Acres
Year built:
1970
Baths:
4.00
MLS#:
3068300
Subdivision:
Peconic Bay

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Beautiful Sunsets From This Mint, Modern, Water-View Estate. Enjoy Heated Water-View Pool, 50+ Linear Ft Of Private, Sandy Beach, Water Garden & Electric Sunshade & Awning For Outside Comfort. Interiors Have Been Freshly Renovated Throughout. New Custom Kitchen W/Honed Carrera Countertops, Solid White Oak Interior Doors, New Baths & Master & Guest Bedroom Suites. Smart Home Features Include Nest Remote Thermostat, Smoke/Co2 Detectors & Security Cameras.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
1.63 Acres
Year built:
1989
Baths:
4.00
MLS#:
3051187

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Stunning Post Modern In Private Setting On 1.6 Acres With 180 Degree Waterviews. Heated Gunite Pool With Bluestone Patio Surround. 4 Bedrooms, 3.5 Bath Including Master Suite With Fireplace And Waterview Balcony. Welcoming Entry, Living Room With Stone Fireplace, Dining Room, Custom Kitchen, Sunroom. Separate Two Car Garage.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,546
Status:
Active
Beds:
2
Lot size:
2.2 Acres
Year built:
1925
Baths:
1.00
MLS#:
3032325

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

This 2.2 Acre Property Allows For So Many Possibilities. Besides Having A 2 Bedroom 1 Bath 1546 Sq Ft Home To Enjoy All Year Round, The Property Offers 1,221 Sq Ft Of Garge Spaces Which Includes 1 Detached Garage By The Home And 3/4 Car Garage Space Behind The Home. Priced To Sell!

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
2,224
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
0.78 Acres
Year built:
1973
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
3014997
Subdivision:
Cove Way

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Renovated Expanded Cape, Annual Taxes Approx $5760. 4 Bedrooms, 3 Baths, Open Floor Pan, Designer Modern Top Of The Line Finishes, New Fixtures And Appliances Including Waterworks Plumbing, E.R. Butler Hardware, Statuary Marble, Havwoods Chevron Flooring, New - Marble, Stainless Kitchen And Baths,New Roof, Windows, Well, Electric, Hvac Heating, Sheetrock, Insulation, Fixtures, Staircase, Deck, Room For Pool, Garage, Finished Basement, Association Water Access Around Corner For Menantic Creek.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
2,950
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
1.12 Acres
Year built:
2001
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
3014603

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Bright&Sunny Contemporary With 2 Master Suites,3 Full Baths,Garage,Full Unfinished Basement,Automatic Propane Generator,Beautifully Landscaped,Fish Pond,Wrap Around Porch,Andersen Windows,Skylights,Redone 2Y Ref.Wood Floors,Firelace In Liv.Room,All Year Round Solarium,Minutes Away From Wade's Beach,Mashomack Preserve,South Ferry,Great Getaway Or Perfect Permanent Residency

Refine Property Search
Page 1 | 2 of 2    Prev | Next
1–25 of 26 properties displayed
Thomas O'Leary, License 10311207479, Xome Inc., License 10991227159, ThomasH.Oleary@xome.com, 844-400-XOME (9663), 57 W 16th St, 2nd Floor, New York, NY 10011


The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. Information. Copyright 2019, Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

How may I help you?

Get property information, schedule a showing or find an agent





Send Request

We respect your privacy