Shelter Island NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale
The median home value in Shelter Island, NY is $850,000.
the county median home value of $385,100.
The national median home value is $219,700.
The average price of homes sold in Shelter Island, NY is $850,000.
Approximately 33.06% of Shelter Island homes are owned,
compared to 3.97% rented, while
62.98% are vacant.
Shelter Island real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Shelter Island real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Incredible Business Opportunity on 1.62 Acres. This centrally located fully operational restaurant accommodates 56 seats, has a market, takeout counter, main dining room, covered porch, outside eating area and spacious commercial kitchen. A country farm stand provides a space for pop-up summer markets . The lager 2550 sqft. workshop creates plenty of options for any entrepreneurial spirit. The farmhouse with 3 bedrooms and 2 Baths makes for the ideal live and work lifestyle .
Superior Built Designer Showcase, Open Floor Plan, 4 bedrooms, 3 baths, near beach with heated saltwater gunite pool, pergula dining patio, fenced gardens with mature landscaping, deck with awning, outdoor shower, firepit, pool shed, attached garage, generator, Belgian block driveway with additional parking.
With a breathtaking view east for sunrises towards Taylor's Island and sunsets to the west through the trees, this amazing property won't last. The tranquility of Coecles Harbor and the remote location surrounds you with amazing wildlife. Make this unique property your own. Come to Shelter Island, there are many means of transportation to bring you here to enjoy the beauty our island offers.
This stunning freshly renovated waterfront home with detached guest apartment and garage could be your new refuge. The open plan living area with vaulted ceiling steps onto an oversize waterfront entertaining deck with sunset views and a private dock. Have it all with 2 master suites, 2 more guest bedrooms plus a private apartment, a chefs kitchen with high end appliances and quartz counters. Plenty of room for a gym, home office and separate kids play/study space. Spread out in 4475 square feet of living area across the main level, finished walkout basement and apartment. The classic brick chimney with double sided hearth serves the main living area and Master bedroom and also provides a pizza oven and hearth in the finished lower level living area. A full house generator for peace of mind plus room for a pool complete this move in ready bucolic dream property. It is only a short bicycle ride to the best area beach or to town for shopping and a bite at the great cafes!
Waterfront home nestled in our treasured Nature Preserve. This cozy 3 bedroom 2 bath home has breathtaking views of Coecles Harbor. With your own private beach and dock you may never leave. Features large kitchen, fireplace, wrap around deck, detached garage. All situated on 1.7 acres of pure nature.
Beautiful 1810 Greek Revival situated on large corner lot shy 1 acre. Makes a fabulous 2 family home with 3 living rooms, 2 kitchens, 5 bedrooms, 3 full bath and screened in porch. One of the few houses built by Gabriel Crook in the early 1800's. Great rental property. Numerous business opportunities. Room for a pool and cottage.
On Peconic Bay side of Shelter Island Sound with 190 feet of waterfront with sandy beach, bulkhead and dock. This 5 bedroom, 3.5 bath beautiful shingle beach house on an acre enjoys beautiful sunsets, magnificent waterviews, waterside decks, mature landscaped lawn, attached 2 car garage and full basement.
SHELTER ISLAND GOLF COURSE HOME WITH POOL This beautiful home is situated on the 16th tee of Gardiner's Bay Country Club. Freshly renovated 4-bedroom, 3-bath home. New baths and kitchen with all new stainless appliances. Private heated gunite pool with stunning golf course vistas. Situated on a beautiful landscaped acre. Exclusive and priced to sell $1,200,000.
Sprawling home on 2.3 acres overlooking the Harbor& Bay w/ nearly 300' of waterfront including a, private boat basin. The home is designed to take in all the beauty of its surroundings, with a layout perfect for entertaining or simply curling up with a good book. Details such as a top of the line kitchen & Smallbone cabinetry throughout further yields that 'one of a kind' feeling you have when you explore this gem. The private road has only 7 homes which share community tennis & waterfront park
How may I help you?
Get property information, schedule a showing or find an agent