Old Lyme CT Real Estate & Homes for Sale
The median home value in Old Lyme, CT is $552,500.
the county median home value of $227,800.
The national median home value is $219,700.
The average price of homes sold in Old Lyme, CT is $552,500.
Approximately 40.78% of Old Lyme homes are owned,
compared to 10% rented, while
49.22% are vacant.
Old Lyme real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Old Lyme real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Life is good at the beach! A wonderful opportunity awaits you at 40 Portland Avenue. This property is comprised of 2 separate year-round dwellings. Get ready to enjoy idyllic summer days as a family compound or collect rental income from one or both! The main house is comprised of 5 bedrooms, 2 kitchens and 2 baths.Â Currently this home possesses the flexibility to be used as a single family or two separate units. Your front door opens into a versatile enclosed sunporch leading to a bright LR, DR and kitchen w an additional side entrance and a tiled bath with shower. Head upstairs to 3 charming bedrooms with closets. ÂA separate access leads you to the quaint 2 BR, LR, bath w shower and kitchen unit.Â Dwelling 2 is an adorable bungalow with a sun-filled enclosed porch, hardwoods, 2 BR, office/storage room, spacious LR and kitchen with attached mudroom. ÂThe property boasts 2 separate on site parking areas for you and your guests. You'll be happy to take advantage of the outdoor shower Âafter some sandy good times at Sound View Beach ' just a short stroll away! Join the optional AssociationÂ (only $60!) and partake in all the fun with scheduled entertainment and events. ÂVacation at home year round and embrace Âthe wonderful restaurants, shopping and activities that make shoreline living in Old Lyme so special!
Location! Location! Location! Investors, Builders, Contractors, Boaters, Beach goers, this is a great opportunity to create the home you dreamed of in a desirable neighborhood! Beach rights available with membership to private Oakridge Beach and there is access to boat ramp. House in need of complete rehab, come in and transform this space into everything you want it to be. Home is being sold "as-is", buyer to do their do diligence. This ranch style home has an open floor plan with 3 beds and 1 full bath on the main level and a bath off master that is plumbed only. The lower level is a full walk out with ability to finish a second kitchen and is plumbed for an additional half bath. Home sits on almost an acre of land and has a horseshoe driveway. Bring your ideas to make this your own oasis! Create a lifestyle for yourself in this water community!
Bargain Beach home with access to two beaches- Soundview Beach & Old Colony Beach!! Tastefully updated 4 bedroom, 2 Bathroom shoreline home ideally located steps away from the water in the Soundview beach front community. Pride of ownership is evident as the current owners have meticulously maintained the home over the course of their 30 + years of ownership. Whether you are sipping your favorite beverage in the front sunroom or enjoying a dinner al fresco on your private rear deck, this home has it all! Several updates include a newer roof(within the last year), newer floors throughout, updated bathrooms with high end finishes and eat-in kitchen with granite countertops. Upon entering this home, a spacious living room awaits you with a brick fireplace, 2 large bedrooms, full bathroom, eat-in kitchen and breezeway leading out to an expansive deck. Moving upstairs you will find an additional 2 bedrooms and a hallway bathroom. Charming home boasting thoughtful landscaping with warm colors creating an ambience of peace and an over abundance of curb appeal! In addition to access to two gorgeous beaches, there is a pavilion at the end of the road with great food and live music. Incredible opportunity to own a truly move-in ready beach home!
AMAZING opportunity awaits! If you're ready for the perfect summer getaway then this cozy bungalow is waiting for you! After being in the same family almost 35 years this slice of property is ready for its new owners. It's only a 3 minute ride to Sound View, has easy access to the main roads and a large enough yard perfect for entertaining all summer long. Enjoy coffee on the enclosed sun porch in the mornings and take a walk or quick ride to the beach for a day in the water and sun. Ample parking makes this property perfect for gatherings after a day in the water or on the boat. The large backyard is great for BBQ's, holiday parties, camp fires and so much more. This unique property holds so much value. Please note: Sold As is
Saturday, 5/28 11:00-1:00PM
New Pricing, to meet the demands to this ever-changing housing market! Welcome to Old Lyme, and it's beautiful coastline. It's time to live the dream by the shore, in this private community called Miami Beach. This lovely, 2 bedroom/one bath ranch style home offers an open floor plan, with beautiful hardwood floors throughout, completely updated for easy living at the shore. This year-round home sits on an oversize corner lot, that allows for complete privacy, to enjoy your own oasis by the sea. 2022 summer in Old Lyme is ready for you to sit back, to enjoy the Sea, Salt and Sand. No flood insurance- outside of flood zone 2020- new split heating air conditioning system 2020- new hot water heater 2021- updated kitchen and new appliances Quartz countertops Washer/ dryer (new) 2021- new septic pump Outdoor hot/ cold shower Hardwood floors throughout
This beautiful home features 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms and over 1,500 square feet of living space with two car attached garage. The kitchen features newer GE stainless steel appliances and center island that opens into the dining room and living room that has a free standing vented propane gas fireplace to keep the home warm and cozy all winter long! A spacious deck is also off the dining room, the first floor offers a bedroom with a large closet and access to a full bath. Two more generous sized bedrooms and a full bathroom with oversized whirlpool tub finish off the second floor both feature ample closet space. The primary bedroom also has a deck that opens up to the peaceful backyard overlooking 4 mile river to enjoy your morning coffee or relax taking in all that mother nature has to offer. The walkout basement has two good size rooms for media/rec room or office along with another full bathroom and sauna. The Laundry room is also located on the lower level with great storage space. This home is located on 4 Mile River Road which is close to major highways, beaches, restaurants and shopping, and conveniently 2 hours from Boston and New York. This home won't last long so schedule your private showing today!
The iconic stone mill on Sill Lane is not only a centerpiece of the town's history and architecture, but also featured in prominent works of art. Built in the early 1800's, the Oliver Lay House on Upper Mill Pond is often depicted in paintings found in books and museums. The mill was fully operational up until the 1950's at which time it was converted into a private residence. This unique property situated along a tributary of the CT river was purposefully built by the damn and pond which creates a backdrop that will delight any nature lover. With over 5,000 sf of living space this home features 4 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, 4 fireplaces along with a garden level living area nestled into the banks of the waterfall. From the main entrance you are greeted by a 2 story grand foyer featuring a wrap around balcony walkway on the 2nd floor that is open to below. With 9' ceilings throughout, the first floor features an expansive formal living room, formal dining room, Â½ bathroom and kitchen with a den perfect for reading or informal dining. Upstairs you will find 4 generously sized bedrooms all with attached or private bathrooms. With it's picturesque landscape setting and historical significance, the mill on Sill Lane is a unique offering that will not disappoint. This is a rare opportunity to own a home that is not only a nature lover's paradise and a piece of history but also a living piece of art.
Welcome home to 2 Katherine Road! This classic dutch colonial style cape has everything you need as a year round residence or summer getaway. Abutting the estuary and Watch Rock nature preserve, there is plenty to do for the Connecticut shoreline enthusiast. Located 500' from the boat access to the Duck River, a three minute drive to White Sands Beach or historic Old Lyme Village, you're close to everything. Enter the front door to find a living room with wide board hardwood floors and a wood burning fireplace. An open concept updated kitchen, dining room and den offer ample space to entertain, and a full bathroom and laundry finish out the first first floor. Walk outside via a slider to the expansive 22X28 dual-level deck and 30X30 stone patio with built in fire pit and grill. Upstairs are three bedrooms with wide board hardwood pine and another full bath. The primary bedroom suite has two expansive closets, and a balcony to take in the beautiful preserve and river views. Central air keeps you cool all summer long. Nothing to do here but move in - come check out this beautiful property while it is still available!
Come and enjoy this newly renovated 3 bedroom, 3 full bath Ranch style home. The kitchen is the heart of the home with a large family room on one end and nice size dining room on the other. The family room has a large wood burning fireplace and French doors that lead out to a deck perfect for entertaining and relaxing. The living room is in the front of the house flowing right back to the kitchen. The lower level has new flooring, with French doors that go directly outside to a lovely patio. Located 2 hrs from Boston and NY. Come see all Old Lyme has to offer.
BACK ON MARKET-BUYER'S LOAN DENIED-NOTHING TO DO W/ THE PROPERTY! Charming & immaculate seasonal cottage at the beach! Only 800 steps to your personal summer oasis...in a neighborhood of well-maintained homes. Enjoy beach walking, swimming, sun bathing, kayaking, shell collecting, picnicking & making new friends at this beautiful beach. Enter your bright & sunny enclosed porch & cozy living room adjoining the eat-in kitchen. Also on main floor, is a bedroom & pristine full bathroom. Outdoor hot shower is another special feature! Assessor card says 1 bedroom, however, the walk-up finished attic has served the current & previous owners well, to provide ample space for beds for overnight guests. Relax in the bright enclosed sun porch while sipping a morning coffee or after a day at the beach. Savor grilled dinners on your spacious wrap-around deck & patio, overlooking your back yard & garden area. This lovingly cared for home features new architectural shingled roof & gutters & downspouts, new energy efficient Harvey windows & new entry door. TWO sheds supply plenty of storage. BOTH SIDES of this adorable cottage provide ample parking for multiple visitors to park vehicles. NO FLOOD INSURANCE is required. Great location-5 min. to driving range, 23 min. to Mohegan Sun Casino, 14 min. to "The Kate" for live theater/concerts, parks, museums & restaurants nearby. Make lifelong memories in Summer 2022.. your first of many future years to enjoy your own beach cottage!
Enjoy living at Hawks Nest Beach! This Year-Round Beach home features open main floor, sunlight sunroom, living room with fireplace leading to dining area and spacious kitchen. Large deck and private backyard for outdoor entertaining. Take advantage of Garvin's store, golf cart parking, a mooring for your boat. Enjoy the magic of beachside living. Begin the dream today that will last generations to come. Possible in law area in finished lower area with private entrance featuring kitchenette, bedroom area and den with fireplace. Two Car attached garage a plus!
Looking for privacy? Always dreamed of a waterfront? Looking for office spaces for your work from home lifestyle? Want a totally renovated property w/nothing to do but move in? Your own slice of heaven in Old Lyme! Direct waterfront w/private dock, boasting 280 feet on pristine Rogers lake, this is the home you've been looking for! Privately sited on 1.5 acres of lovely, level land, this property features a totally renovated 2BR 2 bath main house plus barn/garage/guest apartment w/generous 1st flr workspace, 2nd floor fully appointed studio apartment, plus 2 car garage. Working from home? Use the barn for two separate offices w/kitchenette & full bath. Work totally separate from living space, after work take a few steps to the house for a wonderfully relaxing place to unwind. No expense spared & no detail overlooked, renovations to both the main house & barn include upgrades too numerous to list here. Open floorplan, water views from every room, soaring ceilings & exposed beams, hardwood floors & gorgeous stone fireplace. The waterside LR is open to the dining w/skylight & bay window seat, flanked by closets & beautiful detail. The cook's kitchen is right sized w/gas 4-burner cooktop & oven range, & farm sink. The charming 1st flr bedroom has nice detail. The main house office has granite counters & tons of storage, stackable laundry & full bath w/oversized shower. The 2nd flr master suite is simply stunning, a comfortable retreat, w/sumptuous bath and striking water views.
This absolutely delightful one-level home has a lot to offer! New Roof, updated plumbing, wireless dog fence, 3-4 car attached garage. The flexible floorplan is perfect for entertaining, with a spacious open living room with skylight and hardwood floors that walks into a large kitchen with granite counters and breakfast bar, gas appliances, fireplace, dining area and sun porch. The formal Dining room and living room overlook the back yard that is fully fenced (also has wiring for a wireless dog fence), stone walls, gardens, and a beautiful patio (new in 2021). A generous master bedroom suite with walk in closet, 2nd full bath and 2 bedrooms complete the living areas. Propane fired Buderus Boiler with Hydro air heat and central air conditioning, main level laundry room, walk up attic over the main area of the home, with an additional large pull-down attic that runs the length of the garage which provides additional storage. The home is in pristine condition and in a great neighborhood in OLD LYME!! The Mile Creek side of town with Mile Creek Elementary, Cross Lane Recreational Area with Tennis and Basketball Courts, less than 3 miles to White Sands Beach, 2 Miles to Soundview, Across the Baldwin Bridge to Old Saybrook where you can catch the train to NYC, Boston, or 20 Minutes to the New London Ferry garnering access to Long Island, Block Island and more!
This home will be featured in an upcoming episode of BEACHFRONT BARGAIN HUNT on HGTV! Beautiful year-round home is located only a few blocks from Sound View beach, and just one street over from Hartford Ave - which has dining, ice cream, Italian ice and a carousel! This charming beach town home is approx. 1602 sqft. The first floor features an updated kitchen, open living area, two bedrooms and a full bath. The kitchen has gorgeous granite countertops, new cabinets, a stainless steel refrigerator, dishwasher and stove. There's also a large deck for entertaining! The second floor has a walk-out deck, living room, kitchen, two bedrooms and a full bath! There's an outside entrance and a lockable door separating the first and second floors. There's parking across the front of the property, enough for at least six vehicles! And a detached shed with double doors. The sewage is septic, but the town of Old Lyme will be installing a city sewer. Lot size = 4,792 square feet. There is so much to love about this home! Welcome to the beach!
The 48 acre estate known as 'Quarry House' highlights the best of traditional New England architecture, with an attention to detail and quality expected in a 1930's home. It's not often that a property like this comes to market, but offered for sale for the first time in over 50 years is this wonderful waterfront home and guest cottage on the Connecticut River overlooking gorgeous Pilgrims Landing. The interior open floor plan with elegant dental moulding, exquisite built-ins, custom millwork, arched top doors, and hardwood floors featured throughout the main living spaces. Nestled adjacent to the main home is a fabulous guest house with a kitchenette, bedroom, full bath and amazing views from every room. For the outdoor enthusiast, this home offers many private outside activities including fishing pond, granite ledges, hiking trails, private beach, gunite swimming pool with beautiful bluestone patio and elevated spa. The deep water dock, peninsular boat launch gives you unguarded access to Connecticut River, Long Island Sound and beyond. This stunning one of a kind estate is a paradise for entertaining, basking in the unparalleled sunsets!
Welcome to this charming three bedroom ranch located on a dead end street, in a very quiet neighborhood but close enough to the center of town and shopping. The house has been well cared for, the roof was done 1 year ago, and the plumbing has been replaced with PEX. There are two full baths, a laundry room off the kitchen, and a new refrigerator. The lot is quiet and private with a stone wall across the back of the yard. There is a deck off the kitchen back door. The two car garage offers lots of storage space and a newly sealed driveway provides plenty of parking. Some lovely landscaping throughout the yard adds to the charm of this home. Access to Rogers Lake, Town Woods Park and White Sands Beach with town pass.
Gorgeous 180+ degree panoramic view. Your front yard is sand all the way to the waters edge. Easy access to I-95. Large home, could be remodeled to be your dream home. Private gated beach association. One of a kind shoreline property.
This unique home is in the Mies Van Der Rohe modernist style, designed by famed architect Olav Pedersen. Private wooded property sits on a peaceful 5.10 acres, including a detached 4 car garage, in-ground pool, and a fish pond with formal waterfall fixture. The entry way to the property has a custom black panther statue and semicircular driveway, leading properly into the concrete styled home which has cypress wood interior, radiant heated stone flooring, and wood burning fireplaces to set the ambiance. Once inside you can enjoy the setting from the floor to ceiling glass walls. The oversized master bedroom is on the first floor with a generous, full en-suite bathroom. Second master also available upstairs. On the second story has a balcony off the living room that overlooks the pool, the first floor living room also features sliders onto the patio to the pool. New October 2021 boiler, a 400 amp panel, concealed underground power lines, stone walls, and a sauna. Located conveniently close to I-95, route 156, or the train station. Nearby features also include shopping and beaches. Don't miss your opportunity to own one of Connecticut's landmark homes!
This waterfront property, sited high on an exceptional site of just under three acres, has extraordinary panoramic views of the Connecticut River, Great Island and the Long Island Sound. Wide open views extend from Fishers Island to the Old Saybrook Lighthouse are enjoyed from sunrise to spectacular sunsets. The modest summer Cottage was built as a family summer retreat over 70-years ago and has extraordinary nature views in all seasons. With direct access to the Back River, you can launch your kayak and explore the wildlife of the Roger Tory Peterson Estuary Center or cruise the Sound or River in your boat. Old Lyme is known as the home of American Impressionists and is halfway between New York and Boston. It is only minutes to the Village of Old Lyme for shopping, fine dining, art galleries, the Old Lyme Inn, the famed Griswold Museum and Old Lyme Country Club for tennis and golf. This exceptional waterfront property having a superb location has unlimited potential.
New construction in Old Lyme!! Custom farm style home located in beautiful Lords Meadow. Enjoy this single story Farm style home with 500 sq. ft bonus room on second level, perfect for an in-home theater or gym. Kitchen features all the necessities a gourmet chef would love including a 36 inch gas cooktop, double wall ovens, and an oversized island for all your prep work! This subdivision abuts the Lay-Allen Preserve with over 200 acres of hiking trails. Conveniently located near shopping, restaurants, entertainment, healthcare, beaches and golf courses. Old Lyme is midway between Boston and New York City and less than an hour to Hartford and Providence airports.
New construction in Old Lyme!! Custom farm style home located in beautiful Lords Meadow. Enjoy this single story Farm style home with an accommodating floor plan for any lifestyle featuring a large kitchen/dining/great room combo. This subdivision abuts the Lay-Allen Preserve with over 200 acres of hiking trails. Conveniently located near shopping, restaurants, entertainment, healthcare, beaches and golf courses. Old Lyme is midway between Boston and New York City and less than an hour to Hartford and Providence airports.
New construction in Old Lyme!! Rare opportunity to customize your own dream home located in a tranquil setting. This custom designed single story modern style farm house offers an accommodating floor plan for any lifestyle. Designed with front and rear porches to take advantage of the tranquil setting making this home perfect for entertaining and relaxing with guests. This subdivision abuts the Lay-Allen Preserve with over 200 acres of hiking trails. This location offers convenience to shopping, restaurants, entertainment, healthcare, beaches and golf courses. Old Lyme is midway between Boston and New York and less than an hour to Hartford and Providence airports. Amtrak, Shoreline East and Metro North also nearby.
Introducing The Marsh House...a remarkable waterfront Village estate that incorporates a Main residence, sited at 1 Neck Road...originally a sheep barn constructed entirely of stone in 1912, and subsequently renovated with stunning architectural detail including massive floor to ceiling, multi-paned arched windows, beautiful slate roofing and lush, professionally landscaped grounds punctuated by mature gardens and specimen trees, a tennis court and sparkling pool surrounded by naturalistic plantings. Each room of this incredible residence has its own personality, both formal and informal, incorporating soaring ceilings and filled with natural light. Across the generous lower motor court, the unique and charming Boathouse serves as separate guest quarters, complete with a fully updated kitchen, Great Room and upper level bedroom and bath. The third residence C1900, designated as 3 Neck Road and appropriately called the Gate House, is a two bedroom home, sited on its own .96 acre parcel of land with separate access, perfect as additional guest or caretaker quarters. There is also the potential for a separate building lot set away from the Main house. A stunning, newly permitted dock now allows full access to the waterfront for your boating pleasure. All structures merge seamlessly on the expansive 14.6 acre property that fronts directly on the Lieutenant River...and incredibly all this in the heart of Old Lyme Village. Simply irresistible!
Four Mile River Marina is a marine and living opportunity on the New England Coastline located about halfway between New York and Boston, and approximately 45 minutes from both New Haven and Hartford. The marina offers 94 permitted wet slips, a boat ramp, on-site fuel, shop, repair, & storage building, land storage for boats & trailers, customer bathrooms & shower, a 2 bedroom 1 bathroom ranch that is currently rented, and the main home is a 4 bedroom 3 bathroom colonial. The marina has been well maintained in terms of infrastructure and DEEP compliance and has had a number of recent capital improvements. The marina has a strong slip rental history. This is a great marina opportunity for an owner/operator who wants to live on-site. Alternatively, both homes could be rented instead to increase revenue potential. Nestled between Rocky Neck State Park and Point O' Woods beach community, the marina is situated on the Four Mile River in Old Lyme which offers increased protection from most inclement weather coming off the Long Island Sound. The marina is a convenient departure for day trips to the nearby Thimble Islands, the Connecticut River (Essex, Hamburg Cove), Thames River (Mohegan Sun Casino, New London), Mystic Seaport, Fishers Island, Orient Point, Port Jefferson, and many other boating destinations. It is also an excellent departure for trips to Block Island, Newport, Cape Cod, Martha's Vineyard, Nantucket, and many other ports on the shorelines of CT, RI, MA, and NY.
Location Location Location! Hawk's Nest Beach! Come enjoy beach living in this 5 bedroom 3 bathroom cape on Long Island Sound! Amazing views and private beach area. Beautiful trex deck with 180' ocean front view. Updated bathrooms and new kitchen cabinets. Bocce court on property. Beautiful large lot.Close to I-95 for easy access. Close to restaurants, tennis courts and activities. Must see!
How may I help you?
Get property information, schedule a showing or find an agent