Fishers Island NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale
The median home value in Fishers Island, NY is $1,956,000.
the county median home value of $344,500.
The national median home value is $185,800.
The average price of homes sold in Fishers Island, NY is $1,956,000.
Approximately 14.7% of Fishers Island homes are owned,
compared to 2.78% rented, while
82.52% are vacant.
Fishers Island real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Fishers Island real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Let the wonders of island life engulf you from this charming home on the west end of Fishers Island. Ocean and Pond views can be enjoyed while living day to day. Boasting 5 bedrooms, a patio, a formal dining room, and a living area, there is plenty of room to enjoy. Located within walking distance of the center of town, Hay Harbor Club, and South Beach, Braemar provides an ideal location for those who wish to explore the area. Includes a Right Of Way to Hay Harbor just across the street.
Located on a quiet, dead-end street, just a short walk or drive from Dock Beach and the village, this charming west end hideaway is fully winterized and ready for summer or year-round enjoyment. The bright and airy living room features a shiplap vaulted ceiling with French doors opening onto a new deck with pergola, perfect for outdoor entertaining. This house also features a screened porch off the dining room and a mudroom with built-in storage for pantry items and beach gear. The spacious master bedroom has ample room for the addition of an en suite bath. The main house has one full bath and two additional bedrooms, each with a cedar closet. This home also has an outdoor shower and a detached two-car garage with bonus space, ideal as guest housing, a studio or a game room. In addition, the unfinished, walkout basement has plenty of storage space with a newer washer and dryer. Recently re-shingled and re-roofed, this home is ready to host many more wonderful Fishers Island summers.
With a bird's eye view, keep track of the comings and goings of West Harbor. Built in 2002 with exacting attention to detail, this turnkey house is ideal for either a summer residence or a year round home. Perched on a hill it has a commanding view of West Harbor, Pirates Cove and Fishers Island Sound. Although just a short walk to the village, it feels far removed from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. You'll be pleasantly surprised with how well the 4200 sf of finished space adapts to a couple or the needs of a large extended family with children and grandchildren. If you want to retreat into your own space, this is the house. If you love to entertain, this is the house. From small intimate dinners to large parties, both the house and grounds can accommodate!Strategically sited on an approx 2 acre lot, this house offers lovely breezes even in the hottest of weather, and is energy efficient so it is snug during the winter. Three heat exchanger zones and careful planning will appeal to the energy conservationists. A large kitchen with a breakfast peninsula, upgraded appliances and wide plank red oak hardwood floors open to a family room. The tastefully appointed living room with fireplace and family room both have vaulted ceilings and exceptional water views. On the same floor, a Master suite with incredible views, large walk in closet, large master bath with inlaid tile tub.
A rare find, this fully furnished wood shingled cottage is the perfect getaway. Stretch out with a cup of coffee and a good book on your wrap-around front porch as you watch the comings and goings of the island or enjoy the water view. Located within walking distance of the Hay Harbor Club, Halcyon House is a spacious and centrally located 5 bedroom, 2 full bath house on the West End of Fishers Island. Enjoy island living with plenty of room for family and friends a large updated kitchen with stone countertops, formal dining room, and living room with fireplace provide you with all the space you need. With an easily accessible first floor bedroom, this home is ideal for people of all ages to stay in. With an outdoor shower to wash off sandy toes after a day at the beach, this home is fully equipped, large and bright with newly replaced windows and hardwood floors throughout. Priced to sell, as is.
How may I help you?
Get property information, schedule a showing or find an agent