Fishers Island NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale
The median home value in Fishers Island, NY is $1,956,000.
the county median home value of $344,500.
The national median home value is $185,800.
The average price of homes sold in Fishers Island, NY is $1,956,000.
Approximately 14.7% of Fishers Island homes are owned,
compared to 2.78% rented, while
82.52% are vacant.
Fishers Island real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Fishers Island real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Nestled on a hillside among mature trees, flowers and shrubs, Brooks Point is an oasis with views of Fishers Island Sound. Located midway up the gated East End, you will be just a short distance away from all of the everyday necessities and luxurious indulgences that Fishers Island has to offer. Plenty of room for family and friends, this turn-key house boasts 6 bedrooms and 4 full baths. An eat-in kitchen featuring updated appliances with a butlers' pantry and wet bar make entertaining large crowds a breeze, while the formal dining room is perfect for hosting family dinners. The open planned first floor includes a large living room that is home to a brick fireplace with a connected sun room. With a more private bonus room that is perfect for a children's play room or a quiet office, this house has everything you need. Three sets of glass sliding doors open up to the large upper stone patio that overlooks the in-ground heated swimming pool and grounds; perfect for outdoor living space. The second patio extends by the side of the pool making it the ideal spot for sun bathing and lounging. This property is winterized and includes a detached two car garage ensuring plenty of safe storage as well as a generator (as-is) for added peace of mind. Spend lazy summer afternoons next to the pool on the lush grounds. Take a bike ride to the exercise path and explore all the East End has to offer. With an ideal location, Brooks Point truly is a special retreat from the everyday.
This wonderful island home is set on the West End with views towards Hay Harbor and the Connecticut shoreline. Offering privacy and a cozy atmosphere with hardwood floors and abundant natural sunlight throughout. The large kitchen has double ovens and refrigerators '“ perfect for entertaining. The house boasts 11 rooms including 6 bedrooms with 6 baths, family room, a breakfast nook and a living room/dining area with a double-sided fireplace. Enjoy spectacular sunsets and outdoor living with the best of both worlds '“ a sun porch and an open-air porch. The perfect summer retreat conveniently located close to the village and beaches, but privately set on 1.75 acres with an in-ground pool and patio surrounded by beautiful trees and flowering shrubs. Some furniture will be included with sale.
With a bird's eye view, keep track of the comings and goings of West Harbor. Built in 2002 with exacting attention to detail, this turnkey house is ideal for either a summer residence or a year round home. Perched on a hill it has a commanding view of West Harbor, Pirates Cove and Fishers Island Sound. Although just a short walk to the village, it feels far removed from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. You'll be pleasantly surprised with how well the 4200 sf of finished space adapts to a couple or the needs of a large extended family with children and grandchildren. If you want to retreat into your own space, this is the house. If you love to entertain, this is the house. From small intimate dinners to large parties, both the house and grounds can accommodate!Strategically sited on an approx 2 acre lot, this house offers lovely breezes even in the hottest of weather, and is energy efficient so it is snug during the winter. Three heat exchanger zones and careful planning will appeal to the energy conservationists. A large kitchen with a breakfast peninsula, upgraded appliances and wide plank red oak hardwood floors open to a family room. The tastefully appointed living room with fireplace and family room both have vaulted ceilings and exceptional water views. On the same floor, a Master suite with incredible views, large walk in closet, large master bath with inlaid tile tub.
A rocking chair porch welcomes you to this warm and relaxing West End home on a private .50 acre plot. This turn key property, built by the current owners in 2006 and lovingly maintained, boasts 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and a bonus space in the basement. The attached two car garage has many opportunities for expansion with plenty of room for your island cars. An easy walk to the ferry and parade grounds, this home is ideal for year-round living or convenient commuting from New York City and Boston. An ideal natural gathering place to relax with family and friends, the easy to maintain interior is full of light. An up to date island kitchen and breakfast bar opens to the large living room with a wood burning fireplace. Just steps from the main living area is a beautiful deck and patio. Enjoy being surrounded by nature. The deck and terrace provide comfortable seating along with a perfect summer space for entertaining friends and family. With up-to-date mechanicals and energy efficiency year-round, move right in and enjoy peaceful, gracious, and carefree living.
Right off the ferry, this adorable island cottage overlooks Silver Eel Cove. Perfect for year-round community living, a family summer home or a week-end get-away. Enjoy viewing the sunsets on Silver Eel Cove from the spacious upstairs deck with 175 acres of Conservation grasslands and trails next door. Truly a special house, designed by architect James V. Righter, the comfortable interior offers wonderful lighting and lovely quietude. Lounge in the openly planned downstairs or take inspiration from surrounding nature in the upstairs studio that is perfect for an office or sitting area. Spectacular birds-eye views of Fishers Island Sound and Long Island Sound will be yours from your private loft. Steps away from beach and surf casting - experience all that island living has to offer.
This charming 884 square foot Fishers Island cottage is set among mature trees, flowering shrubs, and stone walls. The home features three bedrooms and one bathroom, a central living area, eat-in kitchen, and sun porch. Enjoy relaxing or entertaining on the large elevated sunny deck. Rinse the sand away with the enclosed outdoor shower. Walk out basement with garage and workshop. This home is winterized & well maintained, having a new roof installed in 2015, newer style double paned insulated windows, updated electric panel and vinyl siding. Located on the West End, you will be within walking distance to the beach and market.
How may I help you?
Get property information, schedule a showing or find an agent