Big Indian NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale
The median home value in Big Indian, NY is $520,000.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $189,100.
The national median home value is $185,800.
The average price of homes sold in Big Indian, NY is $520,000.
Approximately 37.96% of Big Indian homes are owned,
compared to 7.4% rented, while
54.63% are vacant.
Big Indian real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Big Indian real estate agent to arrange a tour today! 
View additional info
Courtesy: RUTH GALE REALTY
Faye Storms
ADDITIONAL INFORMATIONRUSTC and PRIVATE LOG CABIN This 3 BR, 2 BA original 1935 Log Cabin rests in The Big Indian Mt. Association in Big Indian NY. Lot is wooded with .50 acre overlooking woods with stream below. Rustic out bldg. fSr future renovations. Gorgeous old world stone 1.5 story fireplace with loft and upstairs BR with twin beds. First floor features kitchen, LR/Dining room, BR and full bath with addition of sleeping porch and one BR and bath. 
View additional info
Courtesy: RUTH GALE REALTY
Faye Storms
ADDITIONAL INFORMATIONTraditional Swiss Chalet in Big Indian Enter another world of elegant and relaxed European Charm. Approx. 1900 SF 4 BR, 2 BA with Mt. views, just 15 min. from Phoenicia and 5 min. to Belleayre Ski Ctr. This meticulously maintained complex features the Main Lodge, a 2 car garage, a Writer's Studio, a Tool Shed and a Handyman Shed all nestled in nooks and crannies within the slope side portion of the 5 acre wooded property bounded by NYS State Lands. Lodge features custom crafted fieldstone fireplace, a tavern room with full bar and special cook's hooded fireplace in the brand new gourmet kitchen with polished stone counters and S.S. appliances. Unique hand crafted doors moldings and trim throughout the interior and exterior. New roofs on lodge and garage, fully insulated, stained glass windows, brand new 4 BR septic systems, and waterfall feature in campfire area, workshop basement and open sun filled TREK decks and custom stone patio, THIS IS TRULY A ONE OF A KIND DWELLING ready to go with SUPERB attention to detail. $699,0008 Cruickshank Big Indian, NY 12410
View additional info
Courtesy: Murphy Realty Group
Darlene Griffin
ADDITIONAL INFORMATIONThe quintessential mountain retreat awaits you on this privately sited 64.5 acre compound with all of the key ingredients to make your getaway something to look forward to. Trails on the land for hiking, cross country skiing and/or dirt biking. Main house has 2 bedrooms (one currently being used as a quiet sitting room) 2.5 baths and has been lovingly & artistically renovated. Large loft area can be used for a good variety of things such as writing, reading, meditating or even sleeping! Just outside of the master bedroom is a large hot tub for those star gazing nights. Guest house has also been tastefully renovated as well with two bedrooms and 1.5 baths. Beautiful stone fireplaces in both houses. Lots of large windows in both structures allows nature in. Listen to the sounds of the rushing creek below the main house. Large inground 40x20 heated swimming pool for those hot summer days. Watch the wildlife on your sizable pond from the screened in gazebo. Fire-pit for roasting marshmallows. Large barn behind main house. Do as much as you want or as little as you desire, this property will fulfill your needs as an escape from the concrete jungle. 
View additional info
Courtesy: RUTH GALE REALTY
Faye Storms
ADDITIONAL INFORMATIONThis amazing property is just minutes to Belleayre Ski center, Peekamoose Restaurant, Phoenicia and Arkville. It features 4 BRs and 3 BAs, with 2 floors of living space and 2 kitchens and 2 Fireplaces with the first floor easily converted to an apt or rental space. Nestled on 5 acres of gently sloping and level hillside with wooded and open acres. Across the lane is a year round stream with easy access. Enormous decks with seasonal mountain views. There is extensive custom vintage tile work throughout with a 2 story stand alone hand built stone fireplace sourced directly from the property. Many custom features in this extremely well built NJ Contractors private home with an easy access 2 car garage and generous parking area. 
View additional info
Courtesy: RUTH GALE REALTY
Faye Storms
ADDITIONAL INFORMATIONRENOVATED FARMHOUSE Ready to move in 1950SF light filled 3BR, 3 Bath super clean circa 1950 Farm house on a 1.15 acre stream side lot with Mt. views. The corner of the Structure is in flood zone. On demand heat and water system with 3 zones. Jacuzzi in fully finished basement. One car attached garage. Brand new 1000 gal. tank CWC installed septic and newly drilled well, METAL roof and Hickory wood floors. Large rear open deck with year round views. Easy access from the town maintained road. Close to Peekamoose Restaurant and just minutes to STATE HIKING TRAILS, BELLEAYRE SKIING, PINE HILL and EVER POPULAR PHOENICIA. $685,000125 Lasher Big Indian, NY 12410
View additional info
Courtesy: Coldwell Banker Village Green
Andrew Condon
ADDITIONAL INFORMATIONAre you looking for a large, privately sited waterfront home with year-round mountain views to enjoy with friends and loved ones? Then look no further. This sprawling, seven bedroom, five bathroom custom log home is the perfect getaway or retreat for those seeking a space large enough to sleep up to 30 guests - with Esopus Creek frontage. Spread out in the living room around the wood-burning fireplace and relax while taking in the views of the woods and manicured lawn just outside. Spend your days outside in the warmer months on over 1,400 square feet of deck space hosting lunches and dinners underneath the stars. The formal dining room boasts impressive cathedral ceilings and a custom river rock stone wood-burning fireplace situated next to the large eat-in kitchen. Wind down in the oversized ground-floor master suite with gas fireplace, full bath, and walk-in closet. Upstairs you"ll find six well-sized bedrooms accessed by three separate staircases, a common space in the center, and three full bathrooms. With over seven acres, there's plenty of room to expand if you wish by adding a pool, tennis court, or guest house with town approval. The current owners presently rent the property via AirBnB year-round and occasionally take in overflow from nearby Full Moon Resort. This property is easily accessible from nearby Route 28, three miles to Belleayre Ski Resort and a short drive to Phoenicia, hiking, shopping, restaurants and so much to do year-round. Be sure to follow the path in the woods to the campfire and to the stunning Esopus Creek! $345,00065 Big Indian Big Indian, NY 12450
View additional info
Courtesy: Gutmann, Nola Realty
Nola Gutmann
ADDITIONAL INFORMATIONSpecial, Secluded, Privacy Galore, Surrounded by Nature. If these are attributes you are looking for, you will have it all at this wonderfully remote, private oasis in the country. Ideal Ski-House; close to ski slopes! Owner is including some of the furniture, so you can move right in. This sunny property is surrounded by hundreds of Acres of protected wilderness preserve & State Lands. Beautiful saltbox contemporary; fully improved. Ideal for entertaining or just for a peaceful get-away. 2 Fireplaces! The massive stone fireplace in the living room and stained glass window set off this totally comfortable living space; plus there is a stucco fireplace with a wood-stove insert in the spacious basement. The huge side deck wraps around the back of the house for extra privacy in your 8 person hot tub. Plenty of space for outdoor BBQ's, entertaining and relaxing. Both the front and side decks can be accessed from the house or yard and overlook the surrounding woods. Ultimate privacy! $195,0008776 Route 28 Big Indian, NY 12410
View additional info
Courtesy: The Catskill Dream Team
Erik Johanson
ADDITIONAL INFORMATIONLIVE-IN investment opportunity. Run a business on the first floor, live in the RECENTLY RENOVATED APARTMENT u-stairs. First floor business currently setup for a pizzeria, restaurant, deli or convenience store with plenty of parking.
1–8 of 8 properties displayed
How may I help you?Get property information, schedule a showing or find an agent |
